Strumenti personali
Tu sei qui: Portale Articoli, libri e interviste - Articles, books and interviews Relativism and Human Rights

Relativism and Human Rights

Claudio Corradetti - 13 maggio 2009 [...] My argument, instead, is that the entire domain of human understanding is sensitive to rule-governed practices based upon what I will term as “experientialism”. To claim that understanding and meaning are strictly embedded within social practices does not amount to say that world’s objects do not exist independently from our cognitive activities. Indeed, too often ontological issues, as those concerning the very existence of an external word, have been confused with the epistemological ones. While ontology is existentially independent from our knowledge, this latter always projects classificatory standards to ontological independent objects both institutional and non institutional [...]

We live in a rule-constrained world. Even our most insignificant practices are somehow dependent upon a socially agreed standard regulating their structures, procedures, and general goals. We can, for instance, appreciate our neighbour’s ability to keep her garden tidy and in good shape, but we can also observe the unusual combination of ingredients in the preparation of an exotic dish, or be impressed

by the refined style of Chinese pots. We can discuss and disagree about whether our moral judgments are sufficiently argued and produce well-founded contrasting arguments. What happens in all cases is that our diverging opinions are defended on the basis of compliance with a rule, a standard which we consider as deserving priority over alternative considerations. If, in contrast to the experiential pervasiveness

of norms, their appreciation were restricted to certain domains of human action, there would be little resistance to the idea of a social construction of reality [...]



Per leggere l'intero articolo Iconapdf.jpg

Questo testo, per gentile concessione dell'editore, è tratto da Claudio Corradetti, Relativism and Human Rights. A Theory of Pluralistic Universalism, Springer, 2009. Si ringrazia Springer per il permesso di utilizzare questi materiali.

Questo documento è soggetto a una licenza Creative Commons
Azioni sul documento